How Do I Check My Home Insurance Claims History Online?
Order a free CLUE report at LexisNexis.com, it lists claims tied to you or your house for the past seven years.
Free to compare
The report matters more if you're holding a non-renewal letter, because insurers pull the same claims history when deciding whether to write you a new policy. Check it for errors first. Look for a claim that was really just a call to an adjuster with no payout, or one tied to a previous owner of the house. If the claims are accurate, that history follows you to the next insurer too. Request the report before you start shopping, not after, so you know what any new insurer will see.
Insurers weigh that claims history differently. One company may decline because of a single water damage claim while another prices around it. With a deadline on your current letter, checking what's available matters more than taking the first offer that will cover a house with your history.
What's actually on a CLUE report, and how do you read it
A CLUE report lists each claim by date, type of loss, and amount paid, along with the address it's tied to. Water damage, wind, fire, theft, liability, it will say which. It also shows claims where nothing was paid out, which matters because those can still count against you even though they cost the insurer nothing. If you called your agent to ask whether something was covered and decided not to file, that conversation sometimes shows up as a claim anyway. That's one of the first things worth checking for.
The report pulls from LexisNexis's own database, built from what insurance companies report to it, not from a government record or your mortgage file. That means it can be wrong in ways that are specific to this system. A claim from a previous owner can attach to the address rather than the person, and if you bought the house recently, their water damage claim from three years ago can show up on your report. Insurers looking at your file won't always catch that distinction. You're the one who needs to.
If you find an error, LexisNexis has a dispute process separate from any insurance company. You can request it online once you've pulled the report, and it typically takes a few weeks to resolve. That's worth starting right away if your non-renewal deadline is close, since a corrected report helps with every insurer you apply to after, not just one.
The report itself doesn't explain why a company dropped you. It just lists what happened. The reasoning, whether it was one claim, a pattern over several years, or something about the house itself, is something only the letter or the insurer said. What the report does is give you the same information the next insurer will see, so there's no surprise partway through an application. Knowing what's accurate on it, and getting anything wrong removed, puts you in a better position before you start asking anyone for a price.
Does a dropped claim still show up, and does it expire
A claim stays on the CLUE report for seven years from the date it was filed, not from when it was resolved or paid out. If you filed something four years ago, it has three more years of showing up before it ages off. There's no way to request early removal just because time feels long enough, the seven years runs on its own regardless of how small the claim was or whether anything was ever paid.
A claim you withdrew or didn't pursue can still sit there for the full seven years. Insurers report what was opened, not just what was paid, so a claim you canceled after getting a repair estimate might still count against you the same as one that paid out in full. This is part of why the report is worth checking closely rather than assuming only the big claims matter.
Some homeowners ask if paying for a repair out of pocket instead of filing keeps it off the record entirely. It does, if no claim number was ever opened with an insurer. The moment an adjuster is assigned or a file is started, even without a payout, it typically gets reported. Whether something reached that point is worth confirming if you remember calling about a problem but aren't sure whether it became an official claim.
None of this changes what already happened, but it does change what to expect going forward. A claim from two years ago will outlast this current letter and follow you into whatever policy comes next, and one from six years ago is close to aging off on its own. Knowing which is which helps make sense of why one insurer's offer looks different from another's, since some companies weigh a claim from five years back very differently than one from last year.
Before you request a quote
Pull the CLUE report first if you haven't, and check the date on every claim listed. One close to aging off soon is worth mentioning when you compare offers.
