What Is a CLUE Report?
It's a record of the claims filed on your house, which insurers check to decide whether to cover you.
Free to compare
The CLUE report is likely why the letter came. Insurers pull this history, going back seven years, before they write or renew a policy. Multiple claims, even small ones you forgot about, can read as a pattern that makes your house a worse bet. Water damage claims draw particular scrutiny because they tend to repeat. You can request your own copy of the report to see exactly what's listed before you apply elsewhere. That way you know what the next insurer will see before they tell you.
Every insurer reads your claims history differently
One company's cutoff for claims or water damage isn't every company's cutoff. Checking your CLUE report first means you can compare coverage from insurers who weigh your history differently.
Can you get an insurer to ignore something on the report
Not exactly, but disputing a wrong entry is worth doing if something on the report is inaccurate. If a claim was closed with no payout, or it's listed as a different type than what actually happened, or it belongs to a previous owner of the house, you can file a dispute with the company that compiles the report. They have to investigate and correct or remove anything that doesn't check out. This won't help with a claim that's accurately listed, but it's worth the few minutes to confirm everything on there actually happened the way it's recorded.
A claim you never filed can end up on your CLUE report too, usually because a contractor or someone else called the insurer directly, or a claim was opened and then withdrawn before any money changed hands. Some of these still show up as an inquiry even without a payout. Depending on the insurer reading the report, an inquiry with no payout carries a lot less weight than a paid claim, but it can still factor in if there are several of them close together.
Time works in your favor here. Most insurers weight recent claims more heavily than older ones, and a claim from six years ago matters less than one from six months ago. The seven-year window on the report means older claims eventually drop off entirely. If you're right at that edge, it can be worth asking when a specific claim is set to age out, since waiting a few months to apply might put you in a better position with certain insurers.
If the claims on your report are accurate and recent, the more useful move is usually not fighting the record but finding an insurer whose underwriting looks past it. Some insurers specialize in covering houses with a claims history that others turn away, and they price for that risk rather than declining outright. The report itself doesn't change, but which doors it closes depends entirely on who's reading it.
How do you get a copy of your own CLUE report
You're entitled to a free copy of your CLUE report once a year, the same way you're entitled to a free credit report. LexisNexis runs the database insurers pull from, and you can request your report directly from them online or by phone. If you've been turned down or non-renewed because of claims history, the denial letter should also tell you how to request the report that led to the decision, and that request is free regardless of your annual check.
The report itself lists each claim by date, type, and amount paid, along with the address it's tied to. Read it against your own memory of what happened at the house. A burst pipe five years ago that cost a few hundred dollars might still be sitting on there, and seeing the full list is the only way to know what an insurer sees before you apply somewhere new.
If you're buying a house, you can ask the seller for the CLUE report on the property itself, separate from any report tied to you personally. Claims history follows the house as well as the person who filed them, so a property with several water damage claims under a previous owner can still affect what it costs to insure, or whether certain insurers will take it on at all. Finding this out before closing gives you time to shop rather than discovering it after you already own the place.
Checking the report costs nothing and takes a few minutes, and it turns a guessing game into a known quantity. Instead of applying blind and hoping an insurer doesn't flag something, you walk in already knowing what they'll find, which makes it easier to explain a claim honestly or to target insurers whose underwriting is more forgiving of what's actually on there.
Before you apply again
Pull your CLUE report and check it against what you remember. If something's wrong, dispute it now, not after another insurer turns you down for it.
