How to Tell if a House Is Insurable
Check the roof's age and condition, the wiring and plumbing, any open claims, and whether insurers still write policies in your area.
Free to compare
What made your house harder to insure is usually written in the letter you got. If it names the roof, an inspector's estimate of how many years are left on it matters more than how it looks from the ground. If it names claims, insurers look at the last five to seven years on a report called CLUE, and two or more claims in that window makes most companies hesitate regardless of cause. If it names old wiring, like knob-and-tube or aluminum, that often has to be replaced before anyone will write a new policy.
Insurers that still write policies in your area don't all weigh the same things the same way. One company may turn down a roof with ten years left while another only hesitates under five. One may overlook a single water claim that another flags. Since your lender's deadline doesn't move, checking what different companies would charge, and whether they'd cover the house at all, matters more now than it did before the letter arrived.
What happens if nobody will insure the house
If every company that writes policies in the area turns the house down, the state has a backstop. It's usually called a FAIR Plan, short for Fair Access to Insurance Requirements. It exists for exactly this situation. It covers the basics, mainly fire and some of the perils a standard policy covers, but not all of them. It costs more than a standard policy for less coverage, and most lenders will accept it because it satisfies the requirement to have insurance on the house. It's a stopgap, not a long-term answer, and it's worth checking what it actually excludes before assuming it covers what the old policy did.
The condition that got the house turned down usually has a fix, and the fix usually changes the outcome. A roof with a few years left can be replaced instead of patched. Knob-and-tube wiring can be pulled out and replaced with modern wiring, which is often what an inspector will say needs to happen before a company will write a policy at all. These fixes cost money up front, but they turn a house that no one will insure into one that several companies will compete over, and that difference matters more than a small premium saving would.
An inspection report, whether from the insurer that dropped the house or one paid for separately, is worth getting in hand before applying elsewhere. It names exactly what needs to change, which means it can be fixed once instead of discovered again by the next company that looks at the house. Bringing that report to a new application, along with proof that an issue has already been addressed, like a receipt for a roof replacement or an electrician's sign-off on new wiring, often moves a house from declined to approved, sometimes with the same company that turned it down the first time.
If the house sits in an area where insurers are pulling back generally, the condition of the house itself may not be the issue, and no repair will change that. That's the case where comparing which companies still write new policies in the area matters most, since the answer has nothing to do with the roof or the wiring and everything to do with where the house is.
How long can a house stay on a FAIR Plan
There's no set limit written into most FAIR Plans. A house can stay on one for a year or for many years, as long as the premium gets paid and the property doesn't get worse. The plan doesn't check back in and push the homeowner toward a standard policy. It just renews, usually once a year, the same as any other policy would.
What usually moves a house off a FAIR Plan is the homeowner applying somewhere else once the problem that caused the decline is fixed or far enough in the past. A roof that had five years left when the house got turned down has more years left after a few seasons pass, and at some point it crosses whatever line the next company sets. Claims age out of the CLUE report that insurers check, typically after five to seven years, and a house with no new claims since starts looking different to an underwriter than it did right after the letter arrived.
Staying on a FAIR Plan longer than necessary usually costs more than it needs to. The coverage is narrower and the price is often higher than a standard policy for the same house, so there's a real cost to treating it as permanent instead of temporary. Checking back with standard insurers every year or two, especially after a repair or once enough time has passed since a claim, costs nothing and sometimes turns up a company willing to write a normal policy again.
Lenders generally accept a FAIR Plan policy because it satisfies the requirement to carry insurance, but it's worth reading what it actually covers against what the mortgage agreement expects. Some FAIR Plans sell limited add-ons for things like liability or theft, and some don't, which can leave gaps a standard policy would have closed. Checking the plan's declarations page against the mortgage terms is worth doing once, so the gap doesn't surface later as a surprise at claim time.
Before the deadline on that letter
Find the date coverage actually ends and check your declarations page for the exact reason listed. Then see what different insurers would say about this house today.
