How Long Do Claims Stay on a CLUE Report?
Claims stay on a CLUE report for seven years, regardless of whether the claim was paid.
Free to compare
The seven-year window explains why a non-renewal letter can still cite a claim from several years back. Insurers pull your CLUE report and look at the full stretch, not just last year. A claim that falls off at year seven stops counting toward this kind of decision. Anything inside the window still shows, including claims you later withdrew or that paid out zero. If your letter cites claim frequency, your CLUE report lists the dates, so you can check which ones are close to aging off before you shop for a new policy.
Since those past claims won't disappear from your record any time soon, the insurer that sees them matters more than the claims themselves. Some weigh frequency and age heavier than others, and a claim from five years back might cost you little with one company and a non-renewal with another. Comparing options now shows which insurers still work with a record like yours, before the current policy runs out.
What else is on a CLUE report besides claims
A CLUE report covers more than the list of claims and their dates. It typically shows the type of loss for each one, water damage, fire, theft, liability, and the amount paid out, if anything was paid at all. It also carries basic details about the property itself, like the address and sometimes the insurer that filed the record. None of this is hidden from you. You're entitled to a free copy of your own CLUE report each year, the same way you can pull a credit report, and reading it before you shop for a new policy tells you exactly what an underwriter will see.
Water damage claims carry particular weight because insurers read them as a sign of ongoing risk, not a one-time event. A single claim for a burst pipe reads differently than two or three water claims over a few years, even if each one was small. Some companies will quote a house with one water claim and decline the same house with two, regardless of the dollar amounts involved. This is part of why the letter you got may cite frequency rather than cost. It's not always about how much the insurer paid out. It's about the pattern.
A claim that was withdrawn, denied, or closed with no payment still shows up on the report for the full seven years. Calling an insurer to ask about storm damage and then deciding not to file still generates a record in many cases, depending on how far the claim went before you withdrew it. This surprises people who assume that only paid claims count against them. If your CLUE report has an entry like this, it's worth checking the details. The report usually notes that no payment was made, and some insurers do factor that in when they underwrite.
CLUE reports follow the property as well as the person. If you're buying a house, the claims history tied to that address can affect what you're quoted, separate from your own record. A seller's past claims, including ones from before they owned it, can sometimes still show up. Asking for the CLUE report on a house you're considering, or asking the seller to request one, is a reasonable step before you commit to buying somewhere with a history of repeated losses.
How do you dispute a mistake on a CLUE report
Errors on a CLUE report happen more often than people expect. A claim might be listed under the wrong date, attributed to the wrong property, or show a payout amount that doesn't match what actually happened. Sometimes a claim that belongs to a previous owner of your house gets attached to your record instead. If an insurer is citing a claim history that doesn't match what you remember, pulling the report and checking each entry against your own memory and paperwork is the first step.
LexisNexis compiles CLUE reports, and disputing an error goes through them rather than through any individual insurer. The process works similarly to disputing a credit report error. You submit the specific entry you believe is wrong along with documentation that supports your version, like a letter from the insurer confirming a claim was closed with no payment, or proof that a claim belongs to a different address. LexisNexis is required to investigate and respond within a set window. If they can't verify the entry, it gets removed.
Disputes take time, often several weeks. That matters if you're already facing a non-renewal deadline. If you spot an error while shopping for new coverage, it's worth starting the dispute right away rather than waiting to see if it affects your quotes first. Some insurers will work with you if you can show a dispute is in progress, even before it's resolved. Others will underwrite based on what the report shows today and leave it to you to follow up once it's corrected.
Not every disagreement with a CLUE report is a factual error. Sometimes the report is accurate but the insurer's interpretation of it is the actual problem, like treating a weather-related claim the same as a maintenance issue. A dispute with LexisNexis won't fix that, since the record itself is correct. In that case, the better move is asking the new insurer directly how they weigh that particular type of claim, or comparing how different companies price the same accurate history.
Check your own report first
Pull your free CLUE report and see which claims are still inside the seven-year window and which are close to aging off. That's what any new insurer will see when you compare options before your current policy ends.
