How Big of Hail Will Damage a Metal Roof?
Hail around 1 to 1.5 inches, golf ball size, can dent or damage most metal roofs, though thicker gauges hold up better.
Free to compare
Why this led to non-renewal
If the insurer flagged hail risk or a past hail claim, that is likely tied to your area's storm history or the roof's material and age. Dents from hail rarely cause leaks. Insurers still price for cosmetic claims, and some pull back from hail-prone counties entirely.
What your old claim paid
Check your prior declarations page or claim history for how hail damage was settled. Some policies pay actual cash value on cosmetic roof damage rather than full replacement cost. That means less money even on a valid claim, and it affects how a new insurer views your risk.
Roof age and gauge
A thicker metal roof holds up better against hail and tends to read as lower risk to a new insurer. If yours is older or a lighter gauge, expect questions about its condition. A new company may want an inspection before agreeing to cover it.
Your deadline and the lender
The cancellation or non-renewal letter states your state's required notice period and the exact date coverage ends. Your lender needs continuous coverage to protect the mortgage. Lining up a new policy before that date matters more than finding the cheapest one.
A hail-related non-renewal from one insurer does not mean every insurer will see your roof the same way. Pricing for hail risk and roof material varies a lot by company, and some weigh gauge and age differently than others. Comparing options before your deadline shows whether another insurer will cover the same roof for less, or at all.
Does cosmetic hail damage matter if the roof still works fine?
Dents that don't leak still count as damage in an insurer's eyes, even if the roof keeps doing its job. Cosmetic damage is the metal being dented or scuffed with no water getting in. Some policies pay for that anyway, others exclude it outright, and a growing number of insurers sell a separate cosmetic damage exclusion endorsement specifically for metal and other roof types. Your declarations page says which applies to you, and it's worth checking before you assume a dent is covered.
If your policy excludes cosmetic damage, filing a claim over dents alone usually goes nowhere, so there's little reason to report it unless there's an actual leak or functional problem. Insurers that write a lot of policies in hail-prone areas have gotten more aggressive about adding these exclusions, because paying to repaint or replace a dented-but-functional roof adds up fast across thousands of claims. If your old insurer added this endorsement before dropping you, a new insurer might offer the same roof full coverage without that carve-out, or might require the same exclusion. It varies by company.
A roof inspection often settles the question before a new insurer even writes the policy. Some companies send someone out, or ask for photos, to judge the roof's current condition and whether old hail damage is cosmetic or structural. If the inspection turns up no leaks and sound metal underneath whatever dents are there, that roof can look like an acceptable risk even to a company that's cautious about hail. The inspection report also becomes useful documentation if a dispute ever comes up later about whether damage is new or old.
Manufacturers rate metal roofing for impact resistance, usually on a scale from Class 1 to Class 4, with Class 4 built to withstand the largest hailstones without cracking or splitting. If your roof carries a Class 4 rating, that's worth mentioning when comparing policies, since some insurers offer a premium discount for impact-resistant roofing and may be more willing to cover it after a hail-related non-renewal. The rating is usually listed on the manufacturer's documentation or the original installation paperwork, not something you can tell by looking at the roof.
Will filing another hail claim make it harder to get covered?
Every claim on your record gets checked when a new insurer prices your policy, not just the hail claim that led to your non-renewal. Insurers pull a claims history report, usually a CLUE report, going back five to seven years. A second or third hail claim on that report, even a small one, can make an insurer price higher or decline the application outright, especially in a county already known for hail.
Small dents are worth thinking about differently once a new policy is in place. Filing a claim for a few hundred dollars of cosmetic damage can cost more in future premium increases than it pays out. Some homeowners pay for minor repairs out of pocket and save the claim for damage that actually affects the roof's function, like a leak or a hole. There's no fixed rule here. It depends on the repair cost, the deductible, and how close the policy is to renewal.
Insurers also weigh how long ago a claim happened. A hail claim from six years ago carries less weight than one from last year, and some companies only look back three to five years rather than the full history. If a non-renewal was triggered by a recent claim, waiting even a year before applying elsewhere can change which companies are willing to write the policy, though that's not always practical with a deadline already set by the current insurer.
None of this means a legitimate claim for real damage should go unfiled. A roof with cracked seams or exposed fasteners after a hailstorm needs repair regardless of how it looks on a claims report, and most lenders require the house to stay in insurable condition. Cosmetic dents and functional damage call for different decisions, and knowing which one is on the roof before calling in a claim can matter for what gets paid afterward.
Before the deadline hits
Find your roof's impact rating on the installation paperwork and pull your claims history. Both shape what a new insurer offers. Compare policies now so coverage is in place before your current one ends.
