Exterior Inspections by Your Insurance Company
Insurers often check a home's roof, siding, and yard from the outside to spot risks before issuing or renewing a policy.
Free to compare
What the inspector looks for
The inspector photographs the roof's condition and age, siding and paint, the foundation, and the yard. Tree limbs over the roof, a trampoline, a pool without a fence, or stored debris can all show up as reasons for the letter you received.
Why the roof matters most
Roof age and wear drive a large share of non-renewals. An insurer may flag a roof over 15 or 20 years old even if it has no leaks, because replacement cost is high and remaining life is hard to judge from the ground.
The letter's deadline
Your state sets how much notice an insurer must give before dropping or not renewing you, and the letter states the actual date coverage ends. Mark that date now, since a lender requiring coverage won't wait for you to shop around later.
What you can fix first
Some issues named in an inspection are quick to address. Trimming trees, fencing a pool, clearing debris, or repairing visible siding damage can all be done before you apply elsewhere. Fixing them first can change how a new insurer prices or decides on your house.
One inspection result from one insurer isn't a verdict on your house. Other companies weigh roof age, claims history, and condition differently, and some work with houses this one won't touch. Comparing options before your deadline shows what coverage actually costs elsewhere, so you're not stuck paying more out of fear that no one else will take you on.
What happens if you disagree with what the inspector found
You can ask the insurer for a copy of the inspection report or photos. Some send them automatically with the non-renewal letter, others only on request. Reading the actual findings matters because letters sometimes cite a general reason like roof condition without stating the specific defect, and the report usually spells out what was seen, whether that's lifted shingles, exposed decking, or granule loss in a particular section.
If the report is wrong, that's worth raising. A roof inspected from the ground or from a drive-by photo can look worse than it is, and a licensed roofer's written assessment showing more remaining life can sometimes change an insurer's decision or at least support your case with a different one. This works better before a policy lapses than after, so get the roofer's report quickly if you plan to use it.
Not every finding is a mistake worth contesting. An insurer pulling back from wood roofs entirely, or capping how old a roof can be at renewal, isn't about your house specifically and won't change no matter what a roofer says. In that case the faster path is finding an insurer whose underwriting rules don't exclude your roof type or age in the first place, rather than spending the weeks before your deadline arguing a policy decision that was never about condition.
Some homeowners get a second exterior inspection done independently before they apply elsewhere, so they can show a prospective insurer current photos and a clean report instead of letting the old finding speak for the house. It costs something upfront, but for a house that's otherwise insurable, it can be the difference between a standard policy and a higher-priced one written on the assumption that the original finding still holds.
Will another inspection happen with the next insurer
A new insurer will likely run its own exterior check before issuing a policy, either by sending someone out, pulling aerial or satellite imagery, or asking for photos you submit yourself. The old report doesn't follow you. Each insurer looks at the house as it stands when you apply, which is part of why fixing what you can before you apply matters.
The method varies by company and by how the house looks on paper already. A roof that's 12 years old with a prior claim might get a closer look than one with a clean history. Some insurers rely mostly on aerial imagery and only send someone out if something looks off from above, like visible damage or a tarp. Others inspect every new policy as a matter of routine, regardless of the file.
If the imagery or photos raise a question, expect a request for more information before the policy is approved, not an automatic decline. That might mean a roofer's statement, closer photos of a specific area, or proof that something flagged, like a pool or an overhanging limb, has been addressed. Responding quickly keeps the application moving instead of stalling it past your deadline.
None of this means the process repeats the same result. A house that one insurer flagged for roof age might pass easily with another whose underwriting allows older roofs if the condition holds up. The new inspection is a fresh look, not a formality, and it's the thing that actually determines your rate and terms, not whatever the last insurer decided.
Before you apply again
Pull out your current letter and check the exact date coverage ends. Fix anything quick, like overhanging limbs or a loose gutter, and have that date ready when you compare insurers below.
